As the NFL’s franchise tag window opens, all eyes are on the Minnesota Vikings and their quarterback situation. Sam Darnold, who played a crucial role in the Vikings’ 2024 campaign, is now at the center of speculation regarding his future. With free agency looming and the Vikings weighing their options, the decision to retain Darnold, pursue a long-term deal, or move in another direction will shape the team’s future.
Darnold’s Journey with the Vikings
Sam Darnold’s path to Minnesota was unexpected. Originally drafted by the New York Jets in 2018, Darnold was seen as a franchise quarterback but struggled with consistency and injuries. After stints with the Carolina Panthers and the San Francisco 49ers, he found himself in Minnesota in 2024 on a short-term deal.
The Vikings brought in Darnold as a backup option behind their presumed starter, but injuries and roster shifts thrust him into the starting role. Darnold exceeded expectations, displaying poise in the pocket, improved decision-making, and a command of the offense that helped the team remain competitive. His performances were solid, if not spectacular, and he showed glimpses of the talent that made him a top pick.
Evaluating Darnold’s 2024 Performance
Darnold’s numbers in 2024 tell an intriguing story. He completed approximately 63% of his passes, threw for over 3,500 yards, and posted a respectable touchdown-to-interception ratio. While not elite, his performance was steady enough to keep the Vikings in playoff contention.
More importantly, Darnold provided stability after the team dealt with uncertainty at the quarterback position. His ability to run play-action effectively and manage the offense within the framework of head coach Kevin O’Connell’s system made him a viable option. However, whether that’s enough for the Vikings to commit to him long-term remains to be seen.
The Franchise Tag Option
With the NFL’s tag window open, the Vikings have the option to place the franchise tag on Darnold. This would ensure he remains with the team for at least another season at a projected cost of around $32–34 million for quarterbacks in 2025.
Pros of Tagging Darnold
- Short-Term Stability – The Vikings wouldn’t have to commit to a long-term deal but would keep a competent quarterback for another season.
- Continuity in the Offense – Darnold has familiarity with the system and coaching staff, which could help in building on last season’s progress.
- Allows More Time for Development – If the Vikings plan to develop a young quarterback, keeping Darnold on a one-year tag buys them time.
Cons of Tagging Darnold
- Expensive Cap Hit – A $32–34 million hit would take up a significant portion of the salary cap, limiting flexibility in other areas.
- Uncertainty About Ceiling – While solid, Darnold has yet to prove he can be a top-tier quarterback. Committing such a high price for one year might not be the best investment.
- Market Alternatives – The 2025 free-agent quarterback class and potential trade options could provide better long-term solutions.
Potential Alternatives for the Vikings
While tagging Darnold is an option, the Vikings could also explore other paths.
1. Drafting a Quarterback
If the Vikings are looking for a long-term answer, they could use the draft to acquire a new quarterback. Depending on their draft position and available prospects, this could be a viable route.
2. Signing a Free Agent
The free-agent market will feature other quarterbacks, some of whom might be more proven or cost-effective. Names like Kirk Cousins (if the Vikings consider a reunion), Baker Mayfield, or even a lower-cost veteran could be explored.
3. Trading for a Quarterback
If the Vikings want to be aggressive, they could explore trades for quarterbacks who might be available, such as Justin Fields, Trey Lance, or others looking for a fresh start.
What’s Next for Darnold and the Vikings?
The decision regarding Darnold’s future will come down to whether the Vikings see him as a bridge quarterback or as their longer-term solution. The team’s cap situation, draft strategy, and overall roster-building philosophy will play a major role in this decision.
With the franchise tag window now open, the Vikings have a limited amount of time to make their choice. Whether they decide to tag Darnold, negotiate a long-term deal, or move in a different direction, their quarterback decision will significantly impact the team’s trajectory for the 2025 season and beyond.