The New York Giants are at a crossroads at the quarterback position. With Daniel Jones entering a critical phase of his career and the team needing a long-term solution under center, the 2025 NFL Draft presents a golden opportunity to secure a franchise signal-caller.
The Giants could be picking early enough to land a top-tier QB prospect, or they may need to trade up to secure their guy. Either way, this draft class boasts several intriguing options who could thrive in Brian Daboll’s offensive system.
Here are our five favorite quarterback fits for the Giants in the 2025 NFL Draft.
1. Carson Beck, Georgia
Height: 6’4” | Weight: 220 lbs | Draft Projection: Top-5 Pick
Why He Fits the Giants
Carson Beck has all the tools to be a Day 1 starter in the NFL. After taking over for Stetson Bennett at Georgia, Beck has showcased elite accuracy, pocket poise, and the ability to make NFL-level throws. His experience in a pro-style offense under Kirby Smart makes him one of the most pro-ready QBs in this class.
The Giants’ offense under Brian Daboll emphasizes timing, anticipation, and quick decision-making—all strengths of Beck’s game. He excels at reading defenses and delivering accurate passes at all levels of the field. His arm strength isn’t quite as cannon-like as some other prospects, but his precision and football IQ make him an ideal fit for New York.
Potential Concerns
- Can he handle pressure behind a shaky Giants O-line?
- Doesn’t have elite mobility, though he’s capable of extending plays.
If the Giants land a top pick, Beck should be at the top of their board.
2. Shedeur Sanders, Colorado
Height: 6’2” | Weight: 215 lbs | Draft Projection: 1st Round
Why He Fits the Giants
Shedeur Sanders has been one of the most electrifying players in college football. Despite playing behind a porous offensive line at Colorado, he has shown elite toughness, arm talent, and playmaking ability. His ability to perform under constant pressure is something the Giants should value, given their own O-line struggles.
Sanders is a natural leader with a competitive edge—traits that would resonate in New York. He has the arm to make every throw and excels in improvisational situations, which could pair well with Daboll’s creative offensive schemes.
Potential Concerns
- Needs to improve his footwork and consistency under pressure.
- Some scouts question his ability to thrive in a structured NFL offense.
If the Giants believe in his upside, Sanders could be a home-run pick.
3. Drew Allar, Penn State
Height: 6’5” | Weight: 240 lbs | Draft Projection: 1st-2nd Round
Why He Fits the Giants
Drew Allar is a prototypical pocket passer with a rocket arm and ideal size for the NFL. While he hasn’t always put up gaudy numbers at Penn State, his physical tools are undeniable. The Giants could view him as a high-ceiling project who could sit behind Daniel Jones for a year before taking over.
Allar’s ability to attack deep and intermediate routes would mesh well with the Giants’ receiving corps, especially if they add another explosive weapon in the draft or free agency. His size also allows him to withstand hits in the pocket—a necessity behind New York’s inconsistent offensive line.
Potential Concerns
- Needs to improve his consistency and decision-making.
- Not a dynamic runner, which limits his upside in today’s mobile QB era.
If the Giants want a traditional pocket passer with upside, Allar is a strong option.
4. Jalen Milroe, Alabama
Height: 6’2” | Weight: 220 lbs | Draft Projection: Late 1st-2nd Round
Why He Fits the Giants
Jalen Milroe is one of the most dynamic dual-threat QBs in this class. After taking over as Alabama’s starter, he showcased elite athleticism, a strong arm, and clutch playmaking ability. His ability to extend plays and create off-script would give the Giants an element they’ve lacked at QB for years.
Daboll has experience working with mobile QBs (see: Josh Buffalo), and Milroe’s skill set could unlock a more versatile Giants offense. His deep-ball accuracy has improved, and his leadership qualities are exactly what New York needs.
Potential Concerns
- Needs to refine his passing mechanics and consistency.
- Can he transition from Alabama’s loaded offense to a Giants team with fewer weapons?
If the Giants want a high-upside playmaker, Milroe could be the answer.
5. Quinn Ewers, Texas
Height: 6’2” | Weight: 205 lbs | Draft Projection: 1st-2nd Round
Why He Fits the Giants
Quinn Ewers has elite arm talent and has thrived in Texas’ high-powered offense. His ability to throw with anticipation and touch makes him an intriguing fit for Daboll’s system. Ewers has improved his decision-making and could be a steal if he falls into the late first or early second round.
The Giants could see him as a developmental QB with starter potential. His chemistry with top receivers (like Xavier Worthy) shows he can elevate his supporting cast—something the Giants desperately need.
Potential Concerns
- Durability has been a question mark.
- Can he handle pressure behind a shaky offensive line?
If the Giants want a high-risk, high-reward pick, Ewers could be worth the gamble.
Final Thoughts
The Giants have a critical decision to make in the 2025 NFL Draft. Do they go for a pro-ready passer like Carson Beck, a dynamic playmaker like Shedeur Sanders, or a high-upside project like Drew Allar or Jalen Milroe?